CarShield spends millions on celebrity ads. We spend that money on claims. Here's what the BBB says — and what real customers have experienced.
Or call us: 803-839-0088
CarShield currently holds an F BBB rating with 700+ closed complaints, primarily for claim denials. Priority Auto Protection is a direct provider with no long-term contracts, starts from $99/mo, and has no unresolved BBB complaints. If you're choosing between the two, the claims track record matters more than the advertising budget.
If you've watched television in the last five years, you've seen the CarShield ads. Ice-T. Vivica A. Fox. Unforgettable jingles. The ads are everywhere — and they're effective at one thing: generating leads. Whether CarShield is equally effective at paying claims is a different question, and the answer isn't encouraging.
CarShield currently holds an F rating from the Better Business Bureau — the lowest possible grade. As of 2024, the BBB has closed over 700 complaints against CarShield, and the company has an accreditation revocation on record. Common complaints center on claim denials, high-pressure sales calls after quote requests, and confusion about what the plan actually covers.
This comparison exists to help you make an informed decision — not to talk you into anything. If CarShield fits your needs, that's fine. But you deserve to know what you're signing up for before you give anyone your credit card number.
| Feature | CarShield | Priority Auto Protection |
|---|---|---|
| BBB Rating | ⚠️ F (BBB accreditation revoked) | ✅ A |
| BBB Complaints (2024) | 700+ closed complaints | No unresolved complaints |
| Contract Type | Multi-year fixed terms | Month-to-month, no commitment |
| Shop Network | ASE-certified shops (restrictions apply) | Any licensed shop nationwide |
| Claims Approval | Mixed; documented denials common | Direct claims, fast turnaround |
| Pricing (est.) | $100–$200/mo depending on plan | From $99/mo |
| Sales Tactics | High-pressure calls reported | No-pressure, transparent quotes |
| Cancellation | Pro-rated refund, fees may apply | Cancel anytime, no fees |
* Competitor data based on publicly available BBB records, consumer reviews, and published pricing. Prices vary by vehicle and plan level.
The Better Business Bureau assigns grades based on complaint history, complaint resolution, transparency, and whether the business honors its commitments. An F is the worst possible outcome — and it's rare. Most companies, even imperfect ones, manage at least a C.
CarShield's F rating reflects a pattern: customers report filing claims, being told repairs aren't covered for reasons not clearly explained upfront, and difficulty reaching claims adjusters. Some report that what was described as a "comprehensive" plan excluded the exact component that failed. The BBB has received and closed more than 700 such complaints, and CarShield lost its BBB accreditation entirely.
That said, some CarShield customers do have repairs covered. The issue isn't that CarShield never pays — it's that claim outcomes are inconsistent, and the exclusion language in contracts is dense enough that consumers frequently discover too late what was and wasn't covered.
A warranty is only worth what it pays when your car breaks down. CarShield's claims process requires you to take your vehicle to an ASE-certified repair facility, have the shop call CarShield's claims line, and wait for an adjuster to approve the repair. Disputes over coverage are common, and repair shops often report friction getting approval.
Priority Auto Protection handles claims directly. Our process: your shop calls the claims line, gets an approval code, and performs the repair. We pay the shop. Most approvals happen same-day. We don't have a third-party claims administrator inserting friction into the process.
CarShield's advertised pricing starts low and escalates depending on your vehicle and coverage level. Some plans marketed as comprehensive come with large lists of excluded components buried in the fine print. The $0-deductible plans cost more; higher-deductible plans lower the monthly cost but shift more risk to you.
Priority Auto Protection is straightforward: plans from $99/mo with clear coverage terms, a standard deductible, and no surprise exclusions. You know what's covered before you buy.
CarShield offers monthly billing, but many plans include cancellation fees or pro-rated refund structures that penalize you for leaving. Some customers report being auto-renewed without clear notification.
Priority Auto Protection is month-to-month. You can cancel any month, no questions asked, no penalties. If you want out, you're out. That's a structural difference — not just a marketing claim.
Still unsure? Call us at 803-839-0088 — no pressure, no scripts, just straight answers.
Get a free, no-commitment quote in 2 minutes. Month-to-month. Cancel anytime. Use any licensed shop.
Get My Free Quote →Or call 803-839-0088